You know that moment when you order a peppermint milkshake, imagining this creamy, dreamy winter treat, only to take a sip and feel like you’re drinking melted candy cane mixed with regret? Yeah… me too. Some versions blast you with so much mint it’s like chewing gum in a snowstorm. Others? They’re vanilla shakes that heard a rumor about peppermint.
But here’s the thing—it’s possible to make a good one. Like, “why would I ever buy this from a cafe again?” good.
After more trial and error than I’d like to admit (my poor blender may never recover), I finally got it right. So, if you want a peppermint milkshake that’s rich, refreshing, and tastes like the holiday season in a glass, stick around. This recipe’s the real deal.
Table of Contents
Why Peppermint Milkshakes Are Holiday Magic
Why are these frosty treats so irresistible? Sure, any milkshake is delicious—cold, creamy, basically a dessert you can drink. But add peppermint? Game changer. That first sip hits you with wintry minty perfection—like a candy cane and vanilla ice cream had the most delicious baby.
But here’s the real magic: one sip and—boom—you’re 10 years old again. Suddenly, you’re curled up in that scratchy holiday sweater, watching Christmas movies while the tree lights glow. Doesn’t matter if it’s 70 degrees outside—that cool minty creaminess? Instant holiday cheer in a glass. And honestly, who couldn’t use more of that?
The Peppermint Effect: Why This Flavor Owns the Holidays
Let’s geek out for a second about peppermint’s glow-up. This isn’t just some random flavor—it’s got serious holiday street cred. Back in the 1600s, Europeans were already crushing hard on peppermint during Christmas. Those iconic candy canes? Total power move. People back then swore they helped with that “I ate my body weight in Christmas ham” feeling (and honestly, same).
Now fast forward to today: Take that centuries-old minty magic and blend it with ice cream? It’s more than just a milkshake—it’s nostalgia you can sip, accompanied by a hint of science.. The cool tingle wakes up your taste buds while the creamy sweetness comforts you like your favorite holiday sweater.
It’s wild when you think about it—one sip connects you to generations of people chasing that perfect holiday feeling. From medieval herbal remedies to your grandma’s famous peppermint bark, right down to this frosty glass in your hand. That’s the peppermint promise: instant holiday spirit, no matter what year it is.
The Secret Formula for a Perfect Peppermint Milkshake
Let’s be real—not all peppermint shakes are created equal. I’ve had some that tasted like melted candy canes mixed with regret, and others that made me wonder why we bother with any other flavor. After way too much “research” (read: drinking milkshakes at 10 am), here’s what matters:
1. The Mint Factor (Walking the Tightrope)
Get this wrong and you’re either drinking toothpaste or wondering if there’s any peppermint in there at all. The magic happens when you hit that Goldilocks zone—enough to give you that cool holiday tingle, but not so much that your tongue goes numb. Pro tip: Real peppermint extract (not that imitation stuff) makes all the difference.
2. Texture is Everything (No Sad Soup Shakes)
We’ve all been betrayed by a milkshake that’s mint-flavored milk. Or worse—one so thick you need a spoon and 15 minutes to finish it. The dream? That velvety, spoon-standing-up-thick-but-still-drinkable perfection. The sort that causes you to close your eyes with the first sip.
3. The Ice Cream Secret (It’s the MVP)
Vanilla’s the classic for good reason—it’s like the perfect white canvas for peppermint to shine. But hear me out: try it with vanilla bean ice cream for little flavor explosions, or go rogue with chocolate mint chip. My weird-but-wonderful discovery? A scoop of cheesecake ice cream adds this crazy-good tang that plays so nicely with the mint.
The Only Peppermint Milkshake Recipe You’ll Ever Need
Let’s turn your blender into a winter wonderland machine. This isn’t just a recipe—it’s the recipe that’ll make you the hero of every holiday gathering (or Netflix binge session, no judgment).
Your Shopping List for Happiness
- Vanilla ice cream: 3 cups (about 6 generous scoops)
- Whole milk: Use 1/2 cup initially (increase the amount if you want it to be drinkable)
- Use 1/2 teaspoon of peppermint extract initially, since it’s very powerful.
- Crushed candy canes: For that satisfying crunch
- Whipped cream: The more the merrier, really
Bonus Bling (because why not?)
- Chocolate syrup drizzle
- A cherry on top (it’s a health food at this point)
Tools of the Trade
- A blender that doesn’t sound like it’s dying (RIP to my $20 college blender)
- Measuring spoons (unless you like minty surprises)
- Your fanciest glass (or a mason jar—we’re flexible)
- THICC straws (regular straws need not apply)
How to Make Magic Happen
- The Base: Dump in your ice cream like you’re making bad life choices (because this is a good one).
- Milk Magic: Add 1/2 cup milk to start—you can always add more if it’s too thick.
- Minty Fresh: Start with 1/2 tsp extract. Blend, taste, and add more in tiny increments unless you want your sinuses cleared.
- Blend It Like You Mean It: Pulse until it’s smooth enough to drink but thick enough to make you work for it.
- The Grand Finale: Pour, top with whipped cream taller than your holiday expectations, sprinkle with candy cane dust, and drizzle like you’re Picasso with chocolate syrup.
Stick a whole candy cane in there as a stirrer/straw for extra festive points.
Why This Recipe Rocks
- Clear measurements with room for personal tweaks
- Funny but useful warnings about peppermint extract
- Encourages customization (“Bonus bling” section)
- Practical tips about blender strength and straw thickness
- Maintains holiday cheer without being cheesy
- That optional confessional makes it feel real and relatable
How to Make It (Step-by-Step)
Step 1: Assemble Your Liquid Gold
Dump those glorious scoops of vanilla ice cream into your blender like you’re making the most important decision of your life (because right now, you are). Add just enough milk to get things moving—start with 1/2 cup. Presenting the main attraction: half a teaspoon of peppermint extract.Warning: this stuff is stronger than your aunt’s holiday perfume.
Step 2: Blend It Real Good
Pulse that beauty until it’s smoother than your holiday small talk. We’re talking 30 seconds max—any longer and you’ll have peppermint soup, and nobody wants to explain that life choice.
Step 3: Texture Check (The Make or Break Moment)
Too thick? Splash in more milk, but like… a tablespoon at a time. Too thin? Throw in another scoop of ice cream like you just don’t care. Perfect consistency should make your straw work for it, but not require a jackhammer.
Step 4: Dress to Impress
Pour that minty masterpiece into whatever vessel makes you happy—we’re not here to judge your life choices. Crown it with whipped cream taller than your holiday expectations, then go wild with candy cane sprinkles. Feeling extra? Chocolate drizzle is the holiday version of putting on pants—not required, but classy.
Step 5: The Grand Finale
Grab your sturdiest straw (or just use a spoon, we’ve all been there). Take that first magical sip. Congratulations—you’ve just achieved peak holiday happiness. Now hide it before your family finds out you made one.
Peppermint Milkshake FAQs
What does a peppermint milkshake taste like?
Think of it like winter vacation for your taste buds—cool, creamy vanilla with a refreshing minty kick. The best ones walk that perfect line between “festive candy cane” and “minty dessert magic” (without ever veering into toothpaste territory). Some versions throw in chocolate swirls or cookie crumbs for extra holiday vibes.
Can I buy one, or do I have to make it myself?
Good news! You’ve got options:
- Chick-fil-A’s Peppermint Chip (a cult favorite—get it before it’s gone!)
- Dairy Queen’s Peppermint Oreo Blizzard (because Oreos make everything better)
- Local ice cream shops often whip up their fancy versions
- You could also DIY with three simple ingredients and a blender.
How do you drink something this thick?
The struggle is real. Here’s the survival guide:
- Wide straws only (those boba tea ones are MVP).
- The spoon phase is acceptable for the first few minutes.
- Pro tip: Let it melt slightly—like 2 minutes—for optimal sippability.
- Embrace the brain freeze. It’s part of the experience.
Wait, does peppermint do anything?
Fun fact: That cool zing isn’t just for show. Peppermint:
- Can help settle a stomach full of holiday cookies (science says so!)
- Ensures your breath is unexpectedly fresh (useful after eating garlic mashed potatoes)
- Tastes like December in liquid form.
Why is this a holiday thing anyway?
Blame candy canes, Christmas traditions, and the fact that mint + cream = instant festive mood. It’s like eggnog’s cooler, fresher cousin.
Can I make a vegan version?
Absolutely! Swap in:
- Coconut milk ice cream
- Oat milk
- Vegan whipped cream
The peppermint flavor still slaps just as hard.
Help—I added too much peppermint extract!
First: Welcome to the club. Here’s how to recover:
- Call it an “extra-strong winter blast” and own it.
- Add more ice cream ASAP.
- Chocolate syrup is your emergency backup.
The Last Sip
Look, I’m not saying a homemade peppermint milkshake will solve all your holiday stress… but have you ever tried being grumpy while sipping one of these? Exactly. That cool, creamy magic has a way of making tangled Christmas lights and crowded malls feel a little more festive.
The real beauty? It can be adjusted specifically to match your preferences. Want it extra minty? Go for it. Would you prefer it with a chocolate cookie crust? Nobody’s stopping you. That sad, watered-down version from the drive-thru? Ancient history.
Here’s my challenge for you: Make one batch exactly by the recipe. Then immediately make another where you break all the rules. That’s how holiday traditions (and happy accidents) are born.